Nanex ~ 30-Aug-2012 ~ Below One Second
The SEC has stated on more than one occasion that it isn't worth the effort to look
at data in resolutions under one second, because it's just noise. Follow us "down the
rabbit hole" as we drill down from 1 second to 1/1000th of a second and see what we
find. Note: more examples on
The charts below drill
down from 1 second intervals to 1 millisecond intervals in the stock symbol FXS on the
morning of August 30, 2012.
Each chart shows the National Best Bid/Offer spread (NBBO) as gray shading. The top
of the shading is the best ask, and the bottom is the best bid. Changes to the NBBO
are shown as triangles color coded by exchange. Triangles pointing up represent best
bids, triangles pointing down represent best offers.
1. FXS - 1 second interval, showing about 17 minutes of data.
Others might think the column of color in the middle is just noise, or a glitch, or
fat-finger. Let's look closer and see.
2. FXS - 25 millisecond interval, showing about 26 seconds of data.
As we drill down, what looked like single quotes (triangles) above, now appears complex
and involves multiple exchanges (multiple colors).
3. FXS - 5 millisecond interval, showing about 5 seconds of data.
At this resolution, note the white spaces between the gray lines. This indicates that
the NBBO isn't stable, it actually flutters quite rapidly at many different prices.
We couldn't see this fluttering on a resolution as fine as 1/40th of a second (25 millisecond).
Note how many different exchanges are involved .
This might be the work of one HFT shop plugged into at least 4 different exchanges.
4. FXS - 2 millisecond interval, showing about 2 seconds of data.
A pattern starts to emerge. This is anything but noise.
5. FXS - 1 millisecond interval, showing about 1 second of data.
The pattern looks very familiar. This appears to be an algo testing out its ability
to rapidly back away from the market from multiple exchanges when a large, informed
order appears. Based on this chart, it looks like HFT is able to withdraw from multiple
markets in a few milliseconds.