Nanex Research

Nanex ~ 20-Feb-2014 ~ The Last Hurrah?

Another example of earnings news released after Market Close, that affects Market Close

On February 20, 2014, in the stock of Acacia Research Corporation (symbol: ACTG, market cap $730 Million), starting at 127 milliseconds after market closing time (16:00), a large burst of trades appeared from Nasdaq and ARCA, sending the price down 3%, and setting the official close in the stock. The trades from Nasdaq and ARCA were marked with a condition that indicated they were from the regular trading session (9:30 - 16:00) and not the after hours session. After hours trades and quotes from other exchanges rule out the possibility of a delay in the consolidated feed which might cause these trades to appear late. We are confident they executed after 16:00.

Two other stocks had similar patterns - CENX and COMM, and also had earnings news. See chart 3.

See this paper which details our initial discovery of this anomaly that led to several WSJ articles, eventually forcing Business Wire to terminate a special direct earnings news service to High Frequency Traders.

Download a list (pdf) of the trades shown in the charts below.

1. ACTG - showing 1 second of time around market close (15:59:59.650 to 16:00:00.650)
The stack of dots are Nasdaq and ARCA trades which executed after market closing time, but are marked as if they traded during regular trading hours. The last of these trades sets the closing price, which impacts any orders in the Closing Cross.


2. ACTG - Zoomed out to 15:59:43 to 16:00:10.


3. All Trades from Nasdaq and ARCA.
Note the groups of dots that line up: those are trades in ATCG, CENX and COMM from Nasdaq (gray) and ARCA (red). All 3 stocks had earnings announced right after the close. Onlly trades market regular session are shown. Form-T (after hours) trades, are not plotted.

Nanex Research

Inquiries: pr@nanex.net